Rabu, 27 Juni 2012

Critiquing an article

Items to be critiqued (Aj. Busakorn):
1. Journal (level of journal)
2. Title includes independent and dependent variables, population (and design)
3. Author --> search for credential authors
4. Abstract --> compare to journal outline, for experiment study --> add experimental protocol in methodology
5. If any old references --> find out the new one before suggesting.
   References fit with title or not.
6. Methodology --> threat control to avoid bias
7. Overall evaluation --> Good/not, should be replicated or not.

In introduction, write:
1. the reason why select this article
2. Selection process
3. Brief discussion of the article
4. Critique in 4 steps
5. Conclusion 
6. Lesson learned
7. References




Tidak ada komentar:

Posting Komentar